How to Pick the Best Hawaiian Island(s) For Your Vacation
Posted on Mon, Jun 28, 2010 by Sheila
With six great Hawaii islands that you can visit, how do you choose the best island(s) for you? That’s a question that many potential Hawaii visitors wrestle with. Trust me, I’ve been there.
I’ve seen a few surveys that ask a handful of questions and supposedly result in an answer of the perfect island for you. Though I’m often called a Hawaii expert, just for fun, I take these quizzes to see the result. After the result displays, I have to wonder how’d they come up with that answer? The trouble with these surveys is that they are too short and ask odd questions like, “Your perfect day includes hiking to a volcano or lounging on the beach or pampering in a spa or searching for beautiful waterfalls.” Well, I don’t know about you, but I want to do all of the above! I think the results of these simple questionnaires are as effective as picking an answer out of a hat.
Does your ideal vacation include shopping and nightlife? Oahu may be a good fit for you.
So, how on earth do you pick an island or two to visit on your vacation? I have some suggestions and can point you to some great resources that will help you get started.
1. Review the visitors bureau Web site for each island. If a particular island looks interesting to you, order their free island guide. These sites and guides highlight the scenery, cultural activities, and island adventures. The island visitor bureaus give you a good flavor for what each island has to offer.
- Kauai: Visitors Bureau website and page to order free Kauai guide.
- Oahu Visitors Bureau website and page to order Oahu vacation planner.
- Maui Visitors Bureau website and page to order Maui vacation planner. Note that the Maui Visitor’s Bureau also includes the islands of Lanai and Molokai – two lesser visited, but fantastic islands.
- Big Island Visitors Bureau website and page to order a Big Island planner.
- Lanai Visitors Bureau website and page to order a free Lanai travel guide. (Also see the link to order a Maui guide that’s mentioned above.)
- Molokai Visitors Bureau website and page to order a free Molokai travel guide. (Also see the link to order a Maui guide that’s mentioned above.)
You might also benefit from surfing the overall Hawaii Visitors Bureau’s website where you can watch videos, find festivals and quickly get lost in discovering all the wonderful things the islands of Aloha have to offer.
Enjoy hiking? Kauai's loaded with trails that'll get your heart pumping and your eyes popping at the views.
2. Take an island virtual tour. A picture is worth a thousand words and a virtual helicopter tour is worth even more! Though the Blue Hawaiian Helicopter island videos were not generated for the intent of helping a potential visitor choose an island, I think they’re great for just that. It’s one thing to see a still photo, but to see a video is even more useful. Here are links to the individual island videos:
There’s about a half a dozen videos or more for each island, so make sure you check them all out by clicking on the “Area of Interest” navigation on the left as well as the circles on the island maps.
3. Review the newly revised, easy to use Go Visit Hawaii Vacation guides. Though not as fancy as the official visitor’s bureau sites, there’s a great depth of unbiased, practical advice in my island guides. Each guide offers photo highlights of each island, advice on when to go, where to stay, where to play, and where to dine.
- Kauai Vacation Guide
- Oahu Vacation Guide
- Maui Vacation Guide
- Big Island Vacation Guide
- I’ve not written Lanai or Molokai guides yet, but I’ve written plenty of articles about each island. See these links for Lanai articles and Molokai articles.
Do you want to go off the beaten path? Lanai has some fun off roading adventures waiting for you.
4. Ask an expert. I’ve vacationed on every island and I know them very well. So, if you have reviewed these resources and you are still not sure which island(s) best suit you, you can ask me. Use the comments to describe:
- What do you like to do on vacation?
- What don’t you like to do on vacation?
- What island(s) are you considering? Are you already leaning towards one or two?
- Have you already identified some must see sights? (For examples: active lava flow, Pearl Harbor, Na Pali Coast)
- What time of year you anticipate you’ll be visiting Hawaii?
- How many days you have in mind for your Hawaii vacation? (Your response will influence the number of islands I’ll recommend for your vacation.)
5. Don’t worry. You can’t make a bad decision. You can have a fantastic Hawaii vacation no matter which island(s) you choose. They all have their own personality and unique features for you to enjoy and admire.
ENJOYED THIS POST? SUBSCRIBE BY RSS OR EMAIL AND GET FREE DAILY UPDATES!
| 
Email This
| 
Print This
Wow Sheila, this post is like an eleven course meal! Lots of great info and stuff to check out. Can’t wait to check out the videos.
[Reply]
Fantastic resources. You are absolutely right about not going wrong which ever island you pick. I’ve been to Oahu, Kauai, Maui and can’t wait to visit the other islands some day. Going back to Oahu in October and I am going to check out their website and page to find something to explore I haven’t seen there yet; I’ve been multiple times, but there is always something new.
[Reply]
Which island(s) to visit?
going for wife’s 50th birthday which is in May.
Would like to relax and enjoy the weather but would also like to take in the sights. Both enjoy physical activity.
coming from the east coast of Canada so would anticipate a 10 day vacation (including travel days).
Thanks,
[Reply]
sheila Reply:
December 12th, 2010 at 10:29 pm
Ian- what you’ve described as your requirements would probably apply to all the islands. With 10 days including travel – that leaves you with 8 full vacation days. You could potentially go to two islands. But, that being said, you won’t run out of things to do if you spend the entire time on just one island. I’ve been to each island multiple times, and I still leave with a list of things I want to do the next time I’m on that island.
I think Kauai might be a good fit for you if ou like physical activity – Kauai has some of the best hiking trails in my opinion. Kauai also has some biking paths. You can kayak the rivers, snorkel the Na Pali coast Line, etc.
Hope that helps. Enjoy your celebration in Hawaii.
[Reply]
hi was looking at going on kaui island was looking at doing some tour. except for the hiking we are limited as we both have back problem. we can do some walking no problem but hours of hiking. we are going in october. was reading and have some concern about the weather. it mention that the island is the wettest island. i thought it didn’t rain much in hawaii overall. can you clearafy this. don’t want to both and have a raining week…
[Reply]
sheila Reply:
February 23rd, 2011 at 12:58 pm
Suzanne – Kauai does tend to get more rainfall that some of the other islands, BUT there are drier areas to stay — like sunny Poipu. See this link: http://www.govisithawaii.com/kauai-where-to-stay/
Also, the rainiest months are usually December and January, so with an October visit, you most likely won’t experience much, if any rain. I have been to Kauai twice in October and I can only recall one daytime rain shower.
Kauai has plenty of beautiful sight seeing that doesn’t require significant hiking. Take a helicopter tour, go on a snorkeling tour, take a catamaran cruise of the Na Pali Coast, see Waimea Canyon,tour a tropical garden, tour a coffee farm … There’s lots of wonderful, but not strenuous things to do on Kauai. See my Kauai vacation guide: http://www.govisithawaii.com/kauai-vacation-guide/
[Reply]
suzanne Reply:
February 23rd, 2011 at 4:21 pm
thank-you for the info…greatly appreciated…
[Reply]
Going to Hawaii August 2011. Celebrating my hubby and my 40th b-day. going with our 14 year old son and 10 year old daughter. want to have cool things to do. Im planning the whole vacation and need ideas. Want to go to Oahu and Maui and possibly Kauai. Dont want to do physical activities like hiking or biking, but def. want to do fun things. Should we start at Oahu which is more active and end the last 5 days in Maui? going for 13 days. HELP!!!
[Reply]
sheila Reply:
March 6th, 2011 at 9:12 pm
Maui and Oahu are probably the best fit. Kauai is more laid back, but definitely a beautiful island for sightseeing. With 13 days, it’s borderline on if it’s a good idea to add a third island or not. Bear in mind that even though the islands are a short flight from each other, you could be spending up to a half a day each time you transfer from one island to another — door to door.
I doubt you’d run out of things to do if you just went to Maui and Oahu. I’ve been to both those island many times and I still have a “to-do” list of things I want to do next time.
I would think starting at Oahu for 6 days and finish on Maui for 7 days.
[Reply]
We are planning our honeymoon for mid October of this year. I told my fiance that I want to “go lay on a beach somewhere romantic” for our honeymoon. Kind of considering Oahu for some of the “Lost” sites…fiance is a chef so we are all about checking out non-chain dining (I have Celiac Disease so need gluten free options). We are not looking to break the bank, and are on a somewhat modest budget…a “fancy” resort is not necessary but we DO want a beachfront room. I’m thinking “lazy honeymoon” with a little shopping nearby. Help!!
Thanks!
[Reply]
sheila Reply:
March 8th, 2011 at 8:44 pm
Tracy – I think you’re on the right track for Oahu. For several reasons:
- It’s the least expensive island in terms of average hotel rates.
- You want a gorgeous beach? Any of the North Shore beaches and Lanikai are spectacular. http://www.govisithawaii.com/2009/05/19/lanikai-beach-one-of-oahus-most-beautiful-beaches/
- Oahu has more restaurants than probably the rest of the islands put together. Oahu is loaded with great restaurants and award-winning chefs. Here are a couple of helpful restaurant articles:
http://www.govisithawaii.com/2008/04/23/where-are-the-best-oahu-restaurants/
http://www.govisithawaii.com/2008/04/25/top-oahu-restaurants-dave-alices-picks/
http://www.govisithawaii.com/2010/11/09/honolulu-magazines-2011-best-hawaii-restaurant-award-winners/
I might suggest that you consider Turtle Bay Resort on Oahu’s North Shore. Almost every room has an amazing oceanfront view. The only downside is that it’s about an hour’s drive into Honolulu. Here’s my review of Turtle Bay http://www.govisithawaii.com/2007/06/27/turtle-bay-resort-review/ In my opinion, it’s one of the most romantic hotels in Oahu. Plus, LOST was filmed on the grounds.
As a fellow LOSTie, you’ll appreciate this article: http://www.govisithawaii.com/2007/07/10/finding-lost-sites-on-oahu/
No matter where you book your hotel, make sure they know it’s your honeymoon. You might just score an upgrade upon availability.
[Reply]
Hi,
Our rather large family (12 Adults, 9 Kids (5 of the kids are infants!)) are looking to spend some quiet family time in Hawaii this August 2011. We are planning on spending a week, so want to pick one of the islands (no island hopping for us). We are mainly looking to soak in some sites, and hang out at the beaches. Hiking and snorkeling are right up our alley (i can’t imagine taking all 21 on a helicopter ride for example…) We want to avoid crowds, and get away from the city. Right now, we are debating the Big Island, Maui, and Kauai. We have all been to Maui, none have visited the other 2. Our fear on the big island is that if we want to see both sides of the island, we will be stuck in the car all day. Any thoughts on what it takes to get from one side to the other? Any recommendations on finding accommodations for such a large group? Many of the travel websites that I have tried (to look for combined air/lodging) have a limit of 12 people.
I am leaning towards Kaua’i, It seems smaller, and more laid back than the rest.
I appreciate any thoughts that you might have, and I very much appreciate this blog!
-
[Reply]
sheila Reply:
March 20th, 2011 at 1:26 pm
Hi Josh,
I think Kauai would be a good fit for what you’re looking for. It is laid back and a great place to soak in the beautiful sites.
With 9 kids and most being infants, you’ll definitely want to go to some of the safer beaches. In my opinion, Kauai has some excellent beaches that tend to be more sheltered and safe. Here are some of the safer beaches on Kauai:
- There’s a keiki (kid) beach at Poipu Beach Park. It’s sheltered, not too deep and definitely fun for kids. Here are a couple of photos from our collection of that beach: http://www.flickr.com/photos/govisithawaii/4590596178/in/set-72157600056337793/ and http://www.flickr.com/photos/govisithawaii/4589973451/in/set-72157600056337793/ There’s no hotel on this beach, so you’d have to drive to get to it.
- If you want to stay in a resort hotel that’s right on a safe beach then the newly refurbished Kauai Marriott would be ideal. See my review for photos http://www.govisithawaii.com/2009/01/02/review-of-kauai-marriott-resort-a-piece-of-paradise/
- Another beach park that’s good for kids and snorkeling, too is Lydgate Beach http://www.kauaiexplorer.com/kauai_beaches/lydgate_beach_park.php that’s on the East Side
The Big Island is also a good choice, but for first timers to the Big Island, ideally, I like to recommend more than a week. And, as you said, you’ll be tempted to want to see both sides of the island, and that might be a tad more challenging with 9 kiddos in tow.
I’ve never tried to book a vacation for more than 4 folks at a time, so I didn’t know that the online sites have a 12 person limit. Do you know of a travel agent that you or your friends have had good service from? You might save a lot of time and headaches by finding a reliable travel agent that knows Hawaii.
Another thought for you, if you wanted to book air separately from accommodation is to try to find a vacation rental. You can save a lot of money, have more privacy, the benefit of a kitchen, etc with a vacation rental. (See this article: http://www.govisithawaii.com/2008/01/30/why-staying-in-a-condo-on-a-hawaii-vacation-is-a-savvy-choice/ ) I’ve met the folks at http://www.kauaivacationrentals.com/ and they seem good to work with, plus they have an extensive list of vacation rental properties for Kauai. (FYI – I don’t get any kickbacks for saying that or making any other recommendation, in case you were wondering.)
[Reply]
Hi Sheila,
I have been put in charge of the ‘difficult’ decision of which island to pick for our multi-generational family vacation. I have narrowed it down to Maui & Kauai. Under different circumstances I would choose Kauai because I’m a hiker and I know Kauai had awesome hiking, however the hiking on this trip will have to be fairly easy & short hikes since I will be hiking with a toddler in a backpack strapped to me. Also, we need to know which island has easy access to the beautiful scenic overlooks, waterfalls, etc. The elderly folks are capable of walking short distances on level ground but nothing too hard. There will be days that we will all want to stay together and sight-see and other days that we will all do our own thing. To be honest I am leaning toward Maui but I really would like to be persuaded toward Kauai. I have this impression that I would not get to see a lot of the most beautiful sites in Kauai since they are difficult hikes (Na’Pali Coast, etc).
What do you like to do on vacation? HIKE, SNORKEL, NATURE, SPENDING SOME TIME AT THE BEACH
What don’t you like to do on vacation? NOT INTO ‘NIGHT-LIFE’ ANYMORE, TOURISTY STUFF, LAYING ON THE BEACH ALL DAY
What island(s) are you considering? Are you already leaning towards one or two?
Have you already identified some must see sights? (For examples: active lava flow, Pearl Harbor, Na Pali Coast) MAUI: ROAD TO HANA, HALEAKELA
KAUAI NO SINCE WE NEED AGE-APPROPRIATE SUGGESTIONS
What time of year you anticipate you’ll be visiting Hawaii? DECEMBER
How many days you have in mind for your Hawaii vacation? (Your response will influence the number of islands I’ll recommend for your vacation.) 9
Originally posted at: How to Pick the Best Hawaiian Island(s) For Your Vacation http://www.govisithawaii.com/2010/06/28/how-to-pick-the-best-hawaiian-islands-for-your-vacation/#ixzz1UZGkQEzJ
[Reply]
sheila Reply:
August 9th, 2011 at 6:46 pm
Hi Kim
Well, I almost think you could flip a coin on your decision.
Kauai offers quite a bit of beautiful sight-seeing that doesn’t require a strenuous hike. For example, see today’s post: http://www.govisithawaii.com/2011/08/09/seeing-kauais-kalalau-valley/ There’s also a couple of beautiful waterfalls that you basically drive to:
http://www.govisithawaii.com/2008/01/22/kauais-wailua-falls/
http://www.govisithawaii.com/2007/07/19/famous-kauai-waterfalls-opeakaa-falls/
See more Kauai sightseeing tips here: http://www.govisithawaii.com/2007/10/09/best-free-activities-on-kauai/
My only concern with Kauai is that you’re planning to be there in December, which tends to be one of Hawaii’s rainier months. Kauai is the wettest island. That being said, you can hopefully avoid rain by staying in sunny Poipu.
Maui’s not a bad choice. For hiking, Haleakala National Park is probably your best bet. There’s two sides to Haleakala http://www.govisithawaii.com/2011/05/02/the-two-sides-of-mauis-haleakala/ The area around Kipahulu has some very good hikes.
Here are some favorite Maui sights and activities — http://www.govisithawaii.com/2008/01/18/top-5-things-you-must-see-and-do-on-your-maui-vacation/
On both islands you should be able to do some humpback whale watching in December, though Maui is better for whale watching. It will be the early part of the season.
Maui also gets more rain in the winter months. Your best bet for avoiding rain is to stay in the South Maui.
Hope that helps in your decision making.
[Reply]
Have a family with 2 kids (5&11) and would like to go to Hawaii – confused on the best island and hotel to stay.
Would like sandy beaches, pools and want to visit Volcanoes. We have 7 to 10 days.
Would like to minimize the travelling between islands if possible.
Any suggestions?
[Reply]
sheila Reply:
September 5th, 2011 at 6:07 pm
Jay – do you want to see volcano activity? Or would seeing a relatively “young” volcanic mountain (Haleakala) suffice? If you want to see volcano activity, then Hawaii’s Big Island is the only island with activity.
If seeing volcano activity is not a high priority, then I’d suggest Maui, which has bunches of beautiful sandy beaches. Maui’s volcanoes are relatively young. Maui also offers quite a bit of fun stuff for kids to do beyond the beaches and pools. They have good luaus, a sugar cane train and more.
Hope that helps.
[Reply]
what would be the best month to go.
Also do you have suggestion for family friendly resorts/hotel – or other lodging choices
Thanks for your advise.
[Reply]
Sheila Reply:
September 5th, 2011 at 8:41 pm
Any time is a good time to go to Hawaii. If there’s one ideal month to go, I’d say May.
There’s tons of family-friendly resorts across Hawaii. Which island are you thinking of?
[Reply]
I am travelling with my parents to Hawaii for 8 days the week straddling the end of October, beginning of December. We’re interested in snorkling, scenery, swimming, boat rides, etc. and culture (can be “culture”). Hiking would need to be relatively short or flat. We’ll probably do 2 islands as this is likely the only trip my parents will take to Hawaii.
I was advised to do Maui and Kaua’i, and I was able to get a good deal at one of the nicer resorts in Princeville for the Kaua’i part, but now I’m worried about the rain? Does end Oct/early Nov count as winter? A lot of the guide books mention things that do not happen in winter but I can’t find a definition of what they consider to be winter. Are we going to be driving south every day? We definitely want to see the canyon and the Napali coast. Do you have to drive south and around to get over there?
Also, thoughts on the selection of the 2 islands. Someone else suggested skipping Kauai and just doing Maui and Oahu but we’re not really into cities at all.
Thanks.
[Reply]
sheila Reply:
September 7th, 2011 at 1:07 pm
Michele — I really wish we had a crystal ball to tell us the weather. It would make life so much easier for us.
Oct/Nov is on the cusp of some of the rainier months in Kauai and Hawaii in general. One thing to bear in mind is that most of Hawaii’s rain falls at night. http://www.govisithawaii.com/2011/04/05/most-of-hawaiis-rain-falls-at-night/
You do have to drive around to the southwest side of Kauai to see Waimea Canyon. Boat tours of the Na Pali coast leave from the South coast at Port Allen. (See my post on exploring the Na Pali Coast by land, air and sea: http://www.govisithawaii.com/2011/04/11/na-pali-coast-by-land-air-sea/)
The Princeville area of Kauai is absolutely gorgeous. You can see Hanalei Bay from there. http://www.govisithawaii.com/2011/03/22/kauais-hanalei-bay/
I wouldn’t hesitate to go to Kauai any time of year. If that helps. We have been to Kauai twice in October and had excellent weather both times.
If you are nervous about rain, consider staying in the Poipu area on the sunnier, south shore. Odds are that you’d avoid rain better there.
I think the Maui/Kauai combination is a good option based on what you described.
You’ll be there just as the humpback whales are arriving back to Hawaii for their annual winter frolic. Maui is perhaps the best island for whale watching.
[Reply]
Hey there! I’ve been enjoying your blog and insight into Hawaii travel. My family of four (10&12yo kids) is planning to travel over Thanksgiving. The things we most want to do are see an active volcano, snorkel, stay on the beach, kids pool, local markets, flora and fauna and geography unique to the Hawaiian islands. Oh, and a luau of course. It’s so hard to choose! We will only have about 5 days (Sat-Sat), so can’t imagine it would be possible to do much island-hopping. We’re not big pop-culture people, so traditional tourism (or eco-tourism!
is probably more our speed. We are of modest means (budget $5-6k for flight+hotel). Is it worthwhile to get a car? Or is public transport reasonably available? Thanks for any insight you can give!!
[Reply]
sheila Reply:
September 11th, 2011 at 12:39 pm
Hi Amy –
If you want to see an active volcano, you have to go to Hawaii’s Big Island for that. It’s the only island with an active volcano.
On the Big Island, there’s some great snorkeling. We have really enjoyed our snorkeling excursions along the Kohala Coast and at Kealakekua Bay.
A challenge with the Big Island is that it really is big. It’s bigger than all the other islands put together. I like to think of the Big Island split in the middle from north to south, making a Hilo side (east) and Kona side (west). Basically all the best beach or ocean side resorts are along the Kona and Kohala Coast. All the volcano activity is on the Hilo side. It’s easy to drive to and from each side in a day. It’s scenic, but takes a couple or so hours depending on where you go.
A rental car is a must in my opinion, there is public transportation on the Big Island, but I think you’d enjoy your experience far more with a rental car. http://heleonbus.org/
As for your budget, I think it might be doable. Take a look at all the detailed links in this article: Top Tips for Saving Money on your Hawaii Vacation: http://www.govisithawaii.com/2011/01/25/top-tips-for-saving-money-on-your-hawaii-vacation/ I have two suggestions, you might want to try to find a vacation condo and I highly recommend you book your flights ASAP with Thanksgiving being only about 3 months away.
Once you’re in Hawaii, most of the best things to do are free or almost free. http://www.govisithawaii.com/2007/10/25/best-big-island-budget-fun/
Check out my Big Island Vacation Guide for a whole lot more advice: http://www.govisithawaii.com/hawaii-big-island-vacation-guide/
[Reply]
Amy Reply:
September 12th, 2011 at 11:33 pm
Thanks so much for your prompt reply! I’ve been trying to digest all your information, and am formulating a plan
. So exciting!
[Reply]
sheila Reply:
November 7th, 2011 at 11:08 am
Hi Amy — glad you found some good information to “chew on”.
Did you make any decisions?
Amy Reply:
November 7th, 2011 at 2:54 pm
Hi Sheila! Yes, we have booked a trip Thanksgiving week to The Big Island, Waikoloa Hilton. Yes, it’s a huge resort, but we like having easy-pleasing options for the kids. But, I really look forward to driving up Mauna Kea, snorkeling, and Kilauea lava flows
. I just started really getting excited about this yesterday, so your note is very timely 
. I’ll be mining your site for more info in the days to come! Any must-sees, nature wise? Thanks!
Amy
[Reply]
sheila Reply:
November 7th, 2011 at 3:19 pm
Awesome!
Definitely start with this article on the best Big Island things to see and do. Off the top of my head Pololu Valley, Waipio Valley, 4-mile scenic drive and the Hawaii Tropical Botanical Garden, Akaka Falls… just to name a few.
I’ll be headed back to the Big Island and staying at the Hilton Waikoloa soon. If you like, follow along with our Go Visit Hawaii facebook page to see photos and experiences from our upcoming Big Island visit.
I hope you enjoy Hawaii Island and come back to tell us what you thought of your visit.
Hi! My motherand a friend of mine are looking to spend about four days on one Hawaiian island. We want to just lay out and relax, so much nightlife is not really needed. This means we would love amazing, not too crowded beaches, but we also want plenty of lush scenery and nature to look at. We want to see the naturally beautiful aspect of Hawaii. However, we’re not too big on hiking. Any suggestions for which island would be best for us? Thanks so much!
[Reply]
sheila Reply:
November 7th, 2011 at 11:21 am
Hi Julia — I just discovered I hadn’t replied to your comment.
Several islands would suit your needs. I would suggest Maui or maybe Kauai for beautiful scenery and uncrowded beaches.
[Reply]
hi
i am planning a trip for myself, my sister and our father. it is his 70th birthday. we are only going to go for a week so we only want to go to 1 island. i have been to maui so i would like to see another island. we r planning on going in january and we want to see a volcano and we love the beach. we also love to go out to great restaurants. what island would u suggest? thank u!!
[Reply]
sheila Reply:
November 7th, 2011 at 11:17 am
Hi Aimee — Maui is always a great choice for first time Hawaii visitors. Since you’ve already been to Maui, my next suggestion for you would be Kauai and staying in the Poipu area. As the lush garden isle, Kauai does get more rain in the winter months, but the Poipu region on the south coast tends to be drier. http://www.govisithawaii.com/2008/09/15/where-to-stay-on-kauai-for-the-best-weather/
Kauai offers some amazing scenery that’s relatively easy to drive to and access. See my post on the best Kauai things to see and do: http://www.govisithawaii.com/2007/10/09/best-free-activities-on-kauai/
There’s lots of great restaurants in the Poipu area of Kauai. See my post about where we enjoyed dining mostly in the Poipu area: http://www.govisithawaii.com/2010/06/08/impressions-from-our-trip-to-kauai-dining/
Kauai is made of a volcano, but doesn’t have an active volcano. If you want to see volcano activity you must go to the Big Island of Hawaii.
[Reply]
Hello Sheila,
First, let me say that I appreciate your blog. It is truly full of valuable information.
I am planning my first trip to Hawaii in November 2012 with my husband to celebrate my birthday. A few friends may come with us. Since this is my first time visiting, I am trying to figure out the best place to go. I have visited other websites (yours was the most informative) and took the “Hawaii test” and was told based off my answers, Maui and Oahu are my best fit but had additional questions I needed answered before I make a decision.
I won’t ask the weather question as you have pretty much clarified that in your earlier
responses. Listed below are the answers to your questions as well as other concerns:
What do you like to do on vacation? I like to sightsee and relax when I go on vacation. I’m not into partying that much but would like to attend a few shows. I also love to shop.
What don’t you like to do on vacation? I am not into water sports or hiking.
What island(s) are you considering? Are you already leaning towards one or two? I am
considering one island, maybe Maui.
Have you already identified some must see sights? (For examples: active lava flow, Pearl Harbor, Na Pali Coast). No, I haven’t identified must see sights.
What time of year you anticipate you’ll be visiting Hawaii? 1st week in November.
How many days you have in mind for your Hawaii vacation? (Your response will influence the number of islands I’ll recommend for your vacation.). I plan to be in Hawaii for 5-7 days.
ADDITIONAL QUESTIONS/CONCERNS
I prefer to fly into one island. My preference is not to have to get on another plane after I land. If I have to, then I understand, but if I can avoid it I will.
Huge selection of stores to shop at.
Huge selection of restaurants to dine. At least a few 5 star.
Whatever island(s) you recommend, can you also tell me the best area on that island to stay?
I really appreciate your feedback.
Thanks!
[Reply]
sheila Reply:
November 28th, 2011 at 4:01 pm
Hi Natalia,
I’m glad to hear that you are finding useful planning information here at Go Visit Hawaii.
I think Maui would be a good fit for you, with one very slight caution, it’s notoverflowing with shopping. That being said, I think you’ll find interesting shopping between historic Lahaina town, Whalers Village in Kaanapali and at the Shops at Wailea. With all the great sightseeing mixed with a little pool or beach relaxation time, you won’t need a lot of time for shopping. By the way, you didn’t mention you were looking for spa time, but just in case, I thought I’d let you know that Maui has some fabulous spas.
Maui has some excellent restaurants — many with ocean views. Here’s our favorite places to dine in Maui: http://www.govisithawaii.com/2008/04/28/how-to-find-the-best-maui-restaurants/
Best area on Maui to stay? I would flip a coin between Wailea and Kaanapali/Kapalua. Wailea has the more “high-end” hotels, but Kaanapali and Kapalua are prettier areas, in my opinion. One of our favorite places to stay on Maui is at the Ritz-Carlton Kapalua. The only caution is that it can get windy there.
Hope that helps. I’ll be interested in hearing what you decide and how it all goes.
[Reply]
My fiance and I are planning a trip to one of the Hawaiian Islands in early October for our honeymoon. Initially we were thinking of Kauai b/c we both love hiking and figured this would be the best island for that reason. We are a little concerned that there won’t be much to do at night though however. Do you know if there are many restaurants/bars open past 10 within walking distance of many of the condos or resorts? We are just afraid that everything will be closed and that there won’t be much to do. We are also looking for a hotel/condo that has ocean front view that is nice but not crazy expensive. Thanks for your help in advance
[Reply]
sheila Reply:
January 3rd, 2012 at 9:17 am
Suzanne — Kauai is a really romantic island and a wonderful place for a honeymoon. However, if nightlife is what you want, you won’t find a great deal on the Garden Isle. There’s some restaurants/bars that offer live music.
One thing to bear in mind is that if you’ll be visit Hawaii from the US Mainland, you’ll be jet lagged for at least a few days. Most likely, you’ll be wanting to wake up early and go to sleep early in the evening. We fly to Hawaii from the East Coast and the first few days we’re in Hawaii, we’re probably asleep between 8:30pm and 10pm.
You can find condos/hotels withing walking distance of restaurants/bars in the Poipu area of Kauai.
[Reply]
Suzanne Reply:
January 3rd, 2012 at 9:30 am
Thanks! Live music to sit down, relax and get a drink or two is all we are really looking for at night. We were just concerned that there would be absolutely nothing open in the evening. Thanks again!
[Reply]
suzanne Reply:
January 3rd, 2012 at 11:16 am
Do you know of the names of the places that have live music off hand?
[Reply]
sheila Reply:
January 3rd, 2012 at 11:56 am
Past 10pm? No. Though at home we stay up past 10pm, with jet lag it’s extremely rare to stay up past 10pm for us in Hawaii — even 9pm.
Most resorts in Hawaii have live music every evening. In Poipu, I’ve heard live music at the Hyatt and the Sheraton. I’m sure there are other places which don’t come to mind.
On the North Shore, we’ve enjoyed live music at Princeville St. Regis and down in some of the shops in Hanalei.
Hi Sheila!
Your website is full of great info!
My hubby and I are going to celebrate our 10yr anniversary in Hawaii this July. We are traveling with our son (8yrs) and our niece (10yrs). I’ve been to Oahu, which I loved, but this will be their first time to Hawaii.
We obviously want a place that has tons of thing to do for kids, but mostly a place with safe beaches where they can swim and play for hours on end. Being from California, the beaches are wonderful but the water is cold and they don’t get to enjoy too much water time at the beach.
My son would love to see an active volcano, but higher on his list is snorkeling and swimming with dolphins.
Your suggestions are much appreciated!
[Reply]
sheila Reply:
January 3rd, 2012 at 11:26 pm
Hi Jennifer,
Based on what you described, I think I know the ideal resort for you, Hilton Waikoloa Village. Here’s why:
- On the Big Island, the only island with an active volcano. Seeing the lava flow and/or glow is truly amazing to see!
- Hilton Waikoloa Village has a neat lagoon with a sandy beach where it’s safe for swimming, snorkeling, stand up paddle boarding, kayaking, etc.
- This resort has a Dolphin Quest on site where you can arrange to swim with the dolphins. (We’ve done the Dolphin Quest in Oahu and it was very good.)
[Reply]
Taking our first trip to Hawaii in September, 2012. Want to visit two islands, spending a week on each. Interested in beaches, pineapple plantations, some sightseeing, good restaurants and nice hotels, preferably a condo unit with kitchen to prepare some meals. What do you suggest? We are traveling from Massachusetts and not sure what airport to use for what islands. Do they each have one airport or more than one? I have so many questions because I want this to be a wonderful trip. Any help yiu can give wiuld be appreciated.
[Reply]
sheila Reply:
January 3rd, 2012 at 11:36 pm
Hi Marilyn –
I know of pineapple plantations on Maui (in Kapalua) and on Oahu (at the Dole Pineapple Plantation). So you may want to include one or both of those islands. For spectacular beaches, Maui and Kauai top my list.
You’ll be able to find nice condos with kitchens on any island you choose.
So, seems like Oahu, Maui and Kauai would all be a good fit for you. They all have excellent sightseeing.
The majority of flights to Hawaii go in and out of Honolulu on Oahu. Each island has one major airport, with the exception of the Big Island which has two major airports. See this post on inter-island travel for more information.
[Reply]
sheila Reply:
January 5th, 2012 at 12:33 pm
Hi again Marilyn — I’ve just published this article on how to choose the right airport in Hawaii. http://www.govisithawaii.com/2012/01/05/flying-to-hawaii-how-to-choose-the-right-airport/
You might find it to be useful for your planning.
[Reply]
Amazing site! I will certainly hit all the links as time allows. Here is our Hawaii vacation challenge: Possibly 2 Hawaii vacations this year.
First one late April or early May with friends. 7-10 days. Between our two families we have 4 kids ages 3-6 at time of travel. Boy and girl age 6, girl age 4, boy age 3.
We like: beach time with water calm enough for the kiddos. Preferably one we don’t have to drive to. Pool time. Fun kid activities (aquarium, local historical sites, museums, plantations). Hiking, yes, but easy, shorter trails. We’d love to get the older (6 year olds) kids snorkeling.
Probably not on the list until the kids are older: zip lines, big water, surfing, cliff diving, long hikes, road to Hana, long scenic drives (two of the kids get car-sick).
Parents are active and like to explore. Moms like spa time if available. We like good dining (Mama’s Fish House on Maui is a favorite) but stay in condos as we dine in more than we eat out.
Not committed to any island. We’ve been to Maui several times, and the Big Island. We prefer to balance major attractions (ie – crowds) with lazy days or spots off the regular route.
Second trip: Sept or Oct. 7 days. Just our family (2 adults, 2 boys age 3 and 6). Done Maui. Love it. Would go again. Done Big Island. Thinking it would be more fun when kids were 6 and 9. Little guy might have a hard time hiking over lava to get to cool beaches. Have time-share options available on Big Island or Kauai. We like off the beaten path but with restaurants, small towns, local sights. As little driving as possible.
Any suggestions are welcome! Thanks!
[Reply]
sheila Reply:
January 9th, 2012 at 4:03 pm
Tricia –
Finding beaches in Hawaii with water calm enough for kids can be challenging. So, I’ll list some beaches that tend to be on the gentle side:
Oahu — Ko Olina, Turtle Bay, though crowded, there are protected sections of Waikiki Beach. All of those beaches have condos within walking distance.
Kauai — Kalapaki Beach, Lydgate Park, and a protected area at Poipu Beach. There are condos within walking-ish distance
You can find good dining and spas on both Oahu and Kauai.
[Reply]
Hello.
My sister and I are planning a trip to one of the island around the end of October for 10 days. Only we’re not sure which one to pick.
Some of things we want to do go snorkeling, hiking small distances,dinner cruise, waterfalls. I love taking pictures especially animals and nature.
Also we will be renting a car, which island is the easiest to drive about, I drive when I have to but don’t really like to. I know sometime we will be heading out very early.
Thank you for your help.
[Reply]
sheila Reply:
January 18th, 2012 at 1:19 pm
Stephanie — just about every island would suit the interests you’ve mentioned. So, let’s focus in on what island is easiest to for driving. In my opinion, Kauai is probably the easiest island. Kauai doesn’t have near as many busy roads as Oahu and Maui do. So, you’ll have less chances for getting lost and less traffic.
[Reply]
Great information here,
My fiance and I are looking to travel to hawaii in Mid October for 6 nights, we are flying from Vegas as part of our honeymoon.
We are from Scotland, both interested in relaxing around beautiful beaches and scenery but also interested in snorkeling and water skiing.
We would love a beach side resort to wake upto in the mornings.
Also we like our nightlife and would be looking for entertainment and bars in the evenings.
Still cannot decide where to go! Any help would be great.
Thanks.
[Reply]
sheila Reply:
January 31st, 2012 at 7:01 pm
Morrison —
If you like nightlife, Waikiki on Oahu or Lahaina on Maui would be ideal.
If you want to do snorkeling, then I might suggest you lean towards Maui slightly only because snorkeling at Molokini is really a special experience. http://www.govisithawaii.com/2007/09/05/hawaiis-molokini-island-a-top-snorkel-and-scuba-diving-spot/
On Maui, look for a hotel in Lahaina (within walking distance of the action on Front Street) or in Kaanapali. http://www.govisithawaii.com/2007/10/08/kaanapali-a-great-base-for-a-maui-vacation/ Kaanapali has a little bit of bars with entertianment. Some Kaanapali resorts offer shuttle service into Lahaina. Unless things have changed, I believe the Sheraton Maui still offers shuttle service into Lahaina:http://www.govisithawaii.com/2009/06/08/review-sheraton-maui-resort-spa/
[Reply]